Part 31 Is Now the Lowest-Rated Star Trek Venture on Rotten Tomatoes

When Star Trek: Part 31 beamed onto Paramount+ final week, it did so with a little bit of a malfunction—and landed with an almighty thud. The primary Star Trek film (streaming or in any other case) in years was instantly scathed by many critics, and now fan reactions have been equally unkind, warping Part 31 proper into first place on essentially the most unglamorous of lists.

As Forbes experiences, Part 31 now holds the “honor” of being the worst-rated Star Trek venture, TV sequence or movie, on vital aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, each when it comes to each a ranking from critics and from consumer enter. Right here’s the complete breakdown of each movie and TV sequence scores:

Star Trek Film Rotten Tomatoes Scores

• Star Trek: The Movement Image: 52% critics, 42% viewers
• Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan: 86% critics, 90% viewers
• Star Trek III: The Seek for Spock: 79% critics, 68% viewers
• Star Trek IV: The Voyage House: 81% critics, 81% viewers
• Star Trek V: The Ultimate Frontier: 23% critics, 25% viewers
• Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Nation: 83% critics, 83% viewers
• Star Trek: Generations: 47% critics, 57% viewers
• Star Trek: First Contact: 93% critics, 89% viewers
• Star Trek: Revolt: 55% critics, 44% viewers
• Star Trek: Nemesis: 38% critics, 49% viewers
• Star Trek (2009): 94% critics, 91% viewers
• Star Trek Into Darkness: 84% critics, 89% viewers
• Star Trek Past: 86% critics, 80% viewers
• Star Trek: Part 31: 20% critics, 17% viewers

Star Trek TV Collection Rotten Tomatoes Scores

• Star Trek: 92% critics, N/A viewers
• Star Trek: The Animated Collection: 94% critics, 81% viewers
• Star Trek: The Subsequent Technology: 92% critics, 90% viewers
• Star Trek: Deep Area 9: 91% critics, 89% viewers
• Star Trek: Voyager: 76% critics, 80% viewers
• Star Trek: Discovery: 91% critics, 33% viewers
• Star Trek: Decrease Decks: 91% critics, 73% viewers
• Star Trek: Picard: 89% critics, 57% viewers
• Star Trek: Prodigy: 97% critics, 88% viewers
• Star Trek: Unusual New Worlds: 98% critics, 79% viewers

Throughout the whole franchise, only one different entry comes even remotely near Part 31 right here within the type of the much-maligned Ultimate Frontier (what does God want with an additional Secret Spock Sibling?), when it comes to both vital response, viewers response, or potential disparity between these two scores. After all, as at all times when discussing Rotten Tomatoes, there are a number of caveats to recollect: the primary is that Rotten Tomatoes scores aren’t a check rating, however a mean share of how many individuals gave a movie or present a constructive critique, numerically valued or in any other case: Part 31 isn’t the equal of a 2/10, as a substitute that merely one in 5 critics rated it positively.

It’s additionally vital to acknowledge that it’s a flawed system, particularly when contrasting historic knowledge previous to its launch in 1998 with knowledge collected for modern materials. That is even extra of a case in relation to viewers scores which undergo from an analogous lack of dependable historic knowledge in addition to the problem that, previous to a number of latest makes an attempt at overhauling how they’re verified and collated, they have been infamously repeatedly manipulated as a part of “overview bombing” harassment campaigns by a myriad of third events and grifters within the tradition conflict. (Working example, Star Trek: Discovery‘s overwhelming disparity between vital and viewers scores on the above checklist, a present that repeatedly confronted bad-faith and racist backlash over the course of its run.) For as vital as the positioning has turn out to be in each the leisure business and, for higher or worse, the best way folks focus on media on-line, taking something notably definitive, constructive or detrimental, comes with the acknowledgement of its flaws.

All that stated although, there in all probability is one thing to take from Part 31‘s largely detrimental response throughout each audiences and critics alike. Not solely does it stand out throughout the oeuvre of Star Trek‘s present streaming period (no matter what detractors of Discovery say about producer Alex Kurtzman’s shepherding of the franchise, by and huge the vast majority of modern Star Trek has been acquired moderately nicely), but it surely speaks to the long-simmering controversy of simply what a Star Trek venture that facilities Part 31—an idea that was controversial from the second it was launched in Deep Area 9—ought to appear to be. Stepping into, the film had a excessive expectation to justify any potential glamorization of an infamously insidious group, one whose very existence was seen as tantamount to a wholesale rejection of Star Trek‘s broader utopian goals. As an alternative, it took an arguably even worse stance than that glamorization in merely doing nothing in any respect with the chance, saying little about both Part 31 as an entity and even actually Star Trek extra broadly.

Star Trek stands at a little bit of a crossroads that its trendy age hasn’t actually seen in fairly some time. The latest conclusions of Picard, Discovery, and Decrease Decks—arguably the flagships that outlined the franchise’s increase within the streaming period—in addition to the unsure way forward for Prodigy after its controversial uncoupling from Paramount+, leaves Trek in a wierd place. Unusual New Worlds, one of the crucial warmly acquired initiatives of this period now stands with only a handful of upcoming initiatives, and, as has been the case since Past‘s launch, whatever the hell is occurring with Star Trek motion pictures stays so nebulous Captain Janeway may go search for espresso inside all of it. Trek wanted Part 31 to show that it may thrive within the streaming film format because it navigates this second of uncertainty—and the ultimate frontier nonetheless may, however it will’ve been a lot better served if it hadn’t began with such a elementary misfire of an concept.

Need extra io9 information? Try when to count on the most recent Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on film and TV, and all the things it’s worthwhile to learn about the way forward for Doctor Who.